Origins of Terror - Is this sword straight or crooked?

The first ones to judge Khalid's actions unfavorably are not the shia, it was the prophet pbuh along with the companions.


Abdulrahman ibn Auf said to khalid "May Allah Fight you"
- Source: Kanzul Ummal Vol.13 page 222 Hadith #36674

The prophet pbuh said about khalid: "O Allah! I am free from what Khalid has done."
- Source: Sahih Bukhari Vol.59 Hadith #628 & Bukhari Vol.89 Hadith #299

Umar bin Khattab said to Khalid "Oh enemy of Allah, you transgressed against a believing man then you married his wife. I would indeed stone you if Allah enabled me.
- Source: Al-Muntadham vol.1 page 440 chapter of "People of Yamama" - on-line version found here --> Al-meshkat Salafi library

But the most damning evidence against Khalid ibn Waleed is his own testimony. This hadith is authenticated by Al-Hakim and is Sahih.

We encountered and killed a people, among them were a Muslim family. Ammar said to me 'these are people who testified to Allah's oneness', but I didn't pay attention to him and did with them as the others (killed them) and Ammar persisted in promising me that he will inform the messenger about what I did.
- Source: Al-mustadra Vol.13 Page 133 chapter "remembering Ammar's merits" on-line version --> al-meshkat salafi library

From Khalid's own words he killed a Muslim family and did not care or pay attention to Ammar when he advised him that these people he just killed are Muslim.
Farsee and Hashim if this was indeed a mistake as you claim then why wasn't Khalid remorseful? why didn't he show regret? why didn't he explain to Ammar it was a mistake?

Yet khalid tells us but I didn't pay attention to him You can dress it up as much as you like but this is no mistake.

In the same hadith by Hakim he tells us that after this event the prophet pbuh was angered with khalid and did not treat him well ever again


Furthermore, the prophet pbuh did not consider khalid a companion. please review the following hadith.
"...There was bad blood between khalid ibn waleed and Abdulrahman bin Auf where Abdulrahman said to khalid (you have taken the custom of Ignorance) Khalid answered him: (no, I took revenge for your father) Abdulrahman says: (you lied, I killed with my own hands the killer of my father, but you took revenge for your uncle al-fakih ibn Mughira), when this news approached the messenger pbuh, he said to khalid: (Oh Khalid, leave alone my companions, by Allah if you were to give mount Uhud's size of Gold in charity in Allhas way you would not achieve what any of companions achieve in a single morning..."
- Source: Al-Bidayah wal Nihayah (ibn khathir) vol.4 page 359
- Source: Tarikh Tabari Vol.2 page 342
- Source: Al-kamil fi al-tarikh Vol.1 page 333 - Chapter "khalids battle on bani Judhaim" on-line version --> al-meshkat salafi library
- Source: Tahdhib Seerah ibn Hisham Vol.1 page 363 on-line version --> al-meshkat salafi library