Imam Bukhari, Author of the most authentic book of hadith for sunnis "Sahih Bukhari" was kicked out of his home city Bukhara because of a strange fatwa. Excuse my lose translation, from this point I will put in my own words (mr bukhari) to identify the person.
Lets read it together.
Even if two children suckle milk from the same animal, it does not count as suckling but counts as eating from the same plate, and Muhammad ibn Ismaeel the one who mentioned this news affirms that the suckling becomes haraam. so He (Imam Bukhari) entered the city of Bukhara around the same time as Shaikh Imam Abu Hafs may Allah have mercy on him; he started declaring fatwas; the shaikh advised him not to do so because he (mr bukhari) has not reached that stage yet. But (mr bukhari) he refused until the day he declared a fatwa on this subject "if two children drink milk of the same calf, the children become haraam to one another." So he (mr bukhari) when asked, affirmed that they are haraam to one another. The scholars gathered against him and kicked him out because of this Fatwa.
Source: Mabsoot Al-sarkhasi Vol. 5 Page 139 and Vol 30 Page 297.
Seriously how funny is that
, According to Bukhari logic, if a boy and a girl drink the milk of the same animal then they can no longer be married and are counted as blood relatives.
Welcome to the twilight zone that is the BAKRI Sect.
Lets read it together.
Even if two children suckle milk from the same animal, it does not count as suckling but counts as eating from the same plate, and Muhammad ibn Ismaeel the one who mentioned this news affirms that the suckling becomes haraam. so He (Imam Bukhari) entered the city of Bukhara around the same time as Shaikh Imam Abu Hafs may Allah have mercy on him; he started declaring fatwas; the shaikh advised him not to do so because he (mr bukhari) has not reached that stage yet. But (mr bukhari) he refused until the day he declared a fatwa on this subject "if two children drink milk of the same calf, the children become haraam to one another." So he (mr bukhari) when asked, affirmed that they are haraam to one another. The scholars gathered against him and kicked him out because of this Fatwa.
Source: Mabsoot Al-sarkhasi Vol. 5 Page 139 and Vol 30 Page 297.
Seriously how funny is that
, According to Bukhari logic, if a boy and a girl drink the milk of the same animal then they can no longer be married and are counted as blood relatives.Welcome to the twilight zone that is the BAKRI Sect.
قال ولو أرضع الصبيان من بهيمة لم يكن ذلك رضاعا وكان بمنزلة طعام أكلاه من اناء واحد ومحمد بن إسماعيل صاحب الاخبار رحمه الله تعالى يقول يثبت به حرمة الرضاع فانه دخل بخارى في زمن الشيخ الامام أبى حفص رحمه الله تعالى وجعل يفتى فقال له الشيخ رحمه الله تعالى لا تفعل فلست هنالك فابى ان يقبل نصحه حتى استفتى عن هذه المسألة إذا أرضع صبيان بلبن شاة [ 140 ] فأفتى بثبوت الحرمة فاجتمعوا وأخرجوه من بخارى بسبب هذه الفتوى
No comments:
Post a Comment